Overview |
Young
hot shot lawyer (although he could easily be a fighter pilot/cocktail mixer) is
so good/cool/sexy he beats everyone he's up against. This time the girl who falls
for him is his boss but they don't actually get down to it (although they do both
get fishy fingers - you'll have to watch the movie to get that) and, folks, don't
fear, Tom Cruise doesn't sing this time... what was the Righteous Brothers follow
up to 'You've lost that loving feeling' anyways... |
Short plot
summary |
|
Tom
Cruise plays
lawyer Lt. Daniel Kaffee under Lt. Cdr. JoAnne Galloway (Demi
Moore) called on to defend two marines (Lance Cpl. Harold W. Dawson played
by Wolfgang Bodison and Pfc. Louden Downey played
by James Marshall) who murdered one of their squad.
But were they acting on orders? Jack Nicholson (Col.
Nathan R. Jessep) knows the answers... |
What our
panel of critics thought |
|
"Top Gun
without the expensive flying shots and no shirt offedness." "My,
Tom does look great in a military uniform." "Everyone
complains that Leonardo DiCaprio looked too young for Titanic, but nobody ever
seems to question Tom Cruise in the same way at this time in movie history." "I
did not understand the baseball references. Please tell me they didn't just add
that in so Cruise could wear a baseball jacket when he was interrogating officers?" "Tom
orders a beer and the waitress doesn't ask him which one? At this time in beer
history there must have been over 5 to choose from! 10 out of 10 for speed, waitress-babe,
but 0 out of 10 for modern waitressing. You just can't get the staff these days..." "I
had a moment of West Wing deja vu when Tom talks to Demi about her asking him
out on a date (the bit when he says something like: 'Are you asking me out on
a date, because someone asked me out on a date one time and it sounded just like
that'). Aaron Sorkin wrote West Wing and he wrote this movie too; did he charge
West Wing again for that piece of writing? I want my money back just in case!" |
Please
tell me the ending.
|
| Well,
it looks like Kaffee (Tom Cruise) is determined to make a stand on principle... In
court, Kaffee calls Col. Nathan R. Jessep (Nicholson) to the stand. Kaffee's only
hope is to get Jessep to admit that he ordered a Code Red (an unofficial marine
order telling the accused to kill the guy they are accused of murdering). Does
Kaffee do it? After a couple of tense moments of looking at each other, a stiff
drink of the finest court water and then Tom lets rip. A shouting match ensues
in which Kaffee gets Jessep to admit he did order it, Jessep is then arrested. The
twist in the tail is that the two guys who followed the order to kill Santiago,
whilst getting off the charge for murder, get a dishonourable discharge for conduct
unbecoming a US marine. |
Quotable quotes (real) |
|
"If
you haven't had a blow job from a superior officer, well, you're just letting
the best in life pass you by." "I'm
a cool guy but this heat is making me absolutely f-wording crazy." [Why
Demi Moore's character is defending the marines:] "Because they stand on
a wall and they say 'nothing's gonna hurt you tonight, not on my watch'." "I'm
gonna rip the eyes out of your head and piss in your skull." |
What position is this movie best enjoyed? |
Saluting yourself
in the mirror. |
Could this
movie be improved with more attitude towards Tom? |
What
is a hunky-late-twenty-something just qualified hot shot lawyer who wears baseball
clothing when questioning officers to do? Tom keeps his shirt on throughout and
still manages to clean up by closing time. |
Does this
film stand up to rigorous reality testing? |
You
either like Tom Cruise playing this kind of lippy young hot shot character or
you don't. It's not as cringy as Top Gun at its worst, probably because the writer
of this movie is Aaron Sorkin (West Wing) - one of the finest. There
are some great moments - Jack Nicholson has some superb lines. However
the ending, just after one of the marines is about to be dishonourably discharged
- when he turns and salutes Kaffee - is truly awful (especially as he had earlier
said he would rather go to prison than be dishonourably discharged because he
wouldn't know what to do with his life afterwards). |
What
can I take from this movie to make me a better person?
|
| Never
do anything Jack Nicholson tells you to do. |
How much
would you pay for a copy of this movie in goods? |
| A
soiled Tom Cruise jock strap. |
Does the
film attempt any dangerous paperwork? If so, does this succeed? |
| There's
not a punch-in-the-kisser in sight, which is a shame. On
the plus side, the verbal aggro is there in mouthfuls. Terrible
missed opportunity for a shirt-off paper-clip fight between Kevin Bacon, Tom Cruise
and Demi Moore. |
Other comments
|
| This
is quite a good movie. Trouble
is, Tom Cruise plays to his annoying 20-something hot shot typecast of the time.
On
the plus side, the movie is very well written and Jack Nicholson (they probably
wrote the role for him in any case) is on form. |
Date
of review |
March
7 , 2005 |